A friend gave me a black and white Keffiyeh he had purchased in Jordan.

I wear it like this. --------------------->
I never gave much thought about what I was "saying" by wearing the scarf. At first, of course, I acknowledged its cultural significance (people in arid climates (a.k.a the Middle East) wear them to provide protection against wind, sand, and sun), but over time I had come to see at as just the-scarf-that-goes-with-everything-and-always-looks-great. I've been wearing it for a few years now (under-the-radar, I suppose) so it came as a surprise to me that twice IN ONE DAY the scarf became the uncomfortable subject of conversation with strangers.
Last Sunday I went to the christening of a friend's baby at a lovely Episcopalian church on the Gold Coast. That morning I picked out a vintage black and yellow cotton dress, perfect for the fall, except that it had short sleeves. Anticipating a drafty church and knowing my body temperature's mercurial nature, I grabbed the scarf for warmth, just to be safe. And you know what? It looked great.
So we're in the part of the mass when you're supposed to greet everyone around you and say, "Peace be with you." It's actually my favorite part of mass because it's one of the rare opportunities you're allowed to speak and be social during the mass' entirety. You get to look at everyone around you, maybe get a little stretch in there...
Well, I turn around, and as I'm shaking this woman's hand, giving her the peace spiel, she leans in and says to me in a not-too-cheery but also not-too-grim way, "Glad to see you're supporting the Palestinians." Huh?!? is what my facial expression must have said. "Your scarf, the black and white is traditionally worn by them." Ohhhhh... I know a few more words were exchanged between us, but all I can remember was thinking, What was her tone? Did she mean she was ACTUALLY glad about me wearing the scarf or was she offended by it? Does she disapprove that I'm wearing this in a church because it's worn by Palestinians? In the span of a few seconds, during which we're all supposed to say the same banal (but pleasant) message, this woman sitting behind me drops some serious shit.

I turned backed around to face the altar. I had plenty of time to think while the priest was taking care of communion and I needed to wrap my head around what happened (no pun intended). Now, was this woman being hostile? (If so, her timing is ironic.) And would someone wearing lush fabrics like green velvet and flamboyant, chunky jewelry (which is what she was wearing, now that I think about it) be hostile at church? And on second thought she seems like the kind of woman who would like Laurel Burch designs and do I think that a Laurel Burch-lover would really be offended by my keffiyeh? Perhaps I need to clarify things with her, but how? When will I get another chance during mass to talk to her?!
Laurel Burch design ----------------------------->
So, while we're standing in our pews, waiting to be ushered into the aisle to line up for communion, I turn back to her, hoping to get a better sense of what she meant. Basically, was this woman being malicious or not?
"I'm sorry, I don't think I understood what you were trying to say to me."
Now, I saw her smile. "I just spent some time in the Middle East, specifically the West Bank. What a lovely place, if you ever can, you should visit. I support the Palestinians and am glad to see you wearing that scarf."
Oh, well that clears things up. Phew! Yes, peace in the Middle East. Of course! I smile, I nod, I feel better now.
Even so, that episode must have made me a little less keffiyeh confident. It must have jumbled up the keffiyeh signal I was sending out, making it impossible for someone to ignore me. Because later that same day I went to buy something from the corner store and the gentleman behind the counter said, upon giving me my change, "I never thought I would see people wearing MY FATHER'S SCARF as a fashion statement."
"Oh, huh," I muttered. And with that, I realized, it's time to put the scarf-that-goes-with-everything-and-always-looks-great into clothing retirement a.k.a the back of the closet. Or at least until I know how to handle the comments it invites.